The Silent Shift: How Law Firms are Quietly Adjusting Pre-OCI Timelines (And How to Adapt)

For years, the standard advice to law students was clear: Prepare for on-campus interviews (OCI) in August, and treat any earlier outreach as bonus networking. But in 2025, that playbook is obsolete. Top law firms have accelerated pre-OCI recruiting, with elite shops making offers as early as May, while Am Law 50 firms are leveraging stealth assessments—like tracking candidates’ engagement with firm-hosted webinars—to rank prospects before OCI even opens. This silent shift leaves students scrambling to decode signals and avoid missteps. Here’s how to adapt.

Pre-OCI Is Now the First Wave of Hiring (Not a Backup Plan)

Firms now fill 56% of summer associate slots through offers made outside of law school interview programs rather than through OCI, according to NALP’s 2024 survey. One Vault 10 firm closed pre-OCI applications for corporate associates by June 1, 2024—weeks before most schools’ OCI deadlines. Another used "coffee chat" invites to discreetly interview candidates via Zoom, with associates scoring candidates on "cultural fit" before formal interviews take place. 

Treat pre-OCI as Phase 1 of hiring. Update your materials by April/May and monitor firms’ LinkedIn/Twitter feeds for unposted deadlines.

The Rise of "Stealth Interviews" (And How to Spot Them)

Firms increasingly mask evaluations as casual interactions. One Vault 10 firm hosted a "Diversity in M&A" panel in April 2024 but required RSVPs to submit resumes—then fast-tracked attendees who asked "insightful" questions. Associates at another such firm noted in a Chambers Associate interview that they’re instructed to "flag standout students" during firm-sponsored moot court competitions.

If an event requires materials in advance or includes a Q&A portion, assume it’s a screen. Prepare like it’s an interview.

LinkedIn Engagement as a Secret Screening Tool

Recruiters at more than one Vault 10 firm have confirmed that they track candidates’ interactions with firm content (e.g., liking posts about recent deals) as a proxy for "authentic interest." For example, one 2L at NYU Law received a pre-OCI invite after commenting on a partner’s article about SPAC regulations, while peers who passively "liked" the post did not.

Engage thoughtfully (e.g., "This case reminds me of [X trend]—how does the firm see this evolving?"). Avoid generic praise. Specificity is the marker of genuine interest, here as in an interview.

The Pressure to Commit Early—And When to Push Back 

Firms have begun issuing exploding offers for pre-OCI candidates, with 72-hour decision windows. But students report that some firms exaggerate slot scarcity. For instance, a Harvard 2L was told "we have only 2 spots left" in May—yet the same firm listed 15+ openings in August. NALP rules technically prohibit such tactics, but enforcement is rare.

If you aren't sure yet when presented an exploding offer, try a response like "I’m honored by the offer and will prioritize a decision. Can you clarify if this deadline is firm, or if extensions are possible for competing offers?"

The OCI Backup Plan: Salvaging a Late Start

If you miss pre-OCI, all isn’t lost:  

-Target high-need groups: Some firms reserve OCI slots for candidates in a particular practice group after pre-OCI favors hires from another. For example, some firms prioritize corporate hires pre-OCI but reserve several OCI slots for litigation candidates.  

-Leverage "second look" invites: Some firms quietly invite pre-OCI rejects to reapply at OCI if they address feedback (e.g., taking a relevant clinic). For example, a UVA 2L who missed a firm's pre-OCI deadline landed an OCI slot by emailing a hiring partner with a 1-page memo on their recent blockchain research—tying it to the firm’s crypto practice.

***

The pre-OCI arms race rewards candidates who treat recruiting like a semester-long campaign, not a August sprint. By recognizing stealth assessments, strategically engaging online, and negotiating offer timelines, you can avoid being sidelined by the silent shift. For students just starting now: Audit firms’ pre-OCI deadlines (many are still unposted!), and remember—OCI remains a viable path for those who pivot fast.